J une
 
 
Class Resources

Acknowledgement: This course was designed with the help of several colleagues around the country, especially Susan Schibanoff (University of New Hampshire), and Charles T. Wood (Dartmouth) whose ideas about teaching Joan's story have deeply influenced my own.
 

English 3357/History 3357: Joan of Arc in History, Literature, and Film

 

Professor Bonnie Wheeler

The extraordinary peasant girl, Joan of Arc (ca. 1412-30 May 1431), as Susan Schibanoff reminds us, is known by many names: la Pucelle, Jeanne (Jehanne) d'Arc, Johanna d'Arc, Giovanna d'Arco, Zhanna d'Ark, The Maid of France/Orleans, die Jungfrau von Orleans. Joan was in the public eye for only two years, between 1429 and 1431, when she was burned at the stake for heresy. Her exploits are nevertheless thought by many to have changed the course of European history. She is one of the most famous and best documented of all historical figures.In this course on biography, national identity, and myth-making we will consider the life and later reception of Joan of Arc through her own trial records and contemporary reports, then through her representation in later literature, film, and propaganda.

If Joan of Arc is one of history's best represented women, she is also among the most scorned. The first part of this course considers Joan's own life as it was viewed by her contemporaries. The next part of the course concentrates on a few major pre-twentieth century images of Joan—the 'precanonization' Joan—especially those that trace the ‘shift from the historical records through the early modern and Enlightenment views of Joan as a harlot or a medieval zealot to the nineteenth-century revisioning of Joan as patriot and pucelle.’ In the final section of the course, we consider various representations of Joan in the twentieth century, starting with the testimony of her sanctification trial and continuing to the images of Joan constructed by Shaw, Brecht, and Anouilh.

What do we know about the extraordinary peasant girl, Joan of Arc (ca. 1412–30 May 1431), who (some claim) in two years changed the course of European history before she was burned at the stake? She is one of the most famous (and best documented) historical figures, and in this course on biography, national identity and identity-anxiety as well as myth-making we will consider the life and later reception of Joan of Arc through her own trial records and contemporary reports, then through her representation in later literature, film, and propaganda.

Required Texts:

Online Reader
Christopher Allmand,The Hundred Year's War;
Jules Michelet, Joan of Arc, (trans. A. Guerard);
Shakespeare, 1 Henry VI (Bantam Classic);
Régine Pernoud with Marie-Véronique Clin, Joan of Arc, Herstory (trans. J. duQ. Adams)
Bonnie Wheeler and Charles T. Wood, eds., Fresh Verdicts on Joan of Arc.

Recommended Texts:

Jonathan Sumption,The Hundred Year's War: Trial by Battle;
Daniel Hobbins, The Trial of Joan of Arc;

On Reserve:

Nadia Margolis, Joan of Arc in History, Literature, and Film: A Select, Annotated Bibliography (1990);
Mark Twain, Personal Recollections of Joan of Arc

 

WEEKLY SYLLABUS AND READINGS
June 3   Introduction
     
    Joan of Arc as Symbol
June 4 Readings Article by Kelly deVries and Preface by Charles T. Wood in Fresh Verdicts.
    Welt, Bernard. “Mythomania”. Art Issues in OLR.
    Winston S. Churchill, “Joan of Arc” in OLR.
    Pierre Nora, “From Lieux de mémoire to Realms of Memory…” in OLR.
  Debates Lawrence D. Kritzman, “Foreword” to Realms of Memory… in OLR.
June 5 Film Joan of Arc (Fleming, dir., starring Bergman/Jose Ferrer. RKO, 1948)

Part 1 - Joan in Her Time

 How did a peasant girl from the fringes of France become the "youngest person of either sex to lead her nation's army before the age of nineteen," as Mark Twain tells us? How do we explain the trajectory of desires, ideas, and events that culminated in her military victory in Orléans and the crowning of her Dauphin as King Charles VII at Reims? Was Joan captured by her enemies with the complicity of her own comrades? Why was she brought to trial for religious rather than military crimes? Why did the trial take so long and why was she executed so precipitously? Did she die a virgin? In this section of the course we consider Joan's youth and family, Joan's silence and speech, and Joan's judges.
    England, France, and the Hundred Year's War: To The Battle of Agincourt.
June 8 Readings Taylor, Joan of Arc: La Pucelle, pp. 1–67.
  Debates        
June 9 Film Kenneth Branagh’s Henry V (1989; 138).
     

June 10

Readings Christopher Allmand, The Hundred Year’s War (Cambridge, 1988).
  Debates  
     
June 10 Readings Christopher Allmand, The Hundred Year’s War (Cambridge, 1988).
  Debates  
     
June 11 Readings Taylor, Joan of Arc: La Pucelle, pp. 68–72.
  Debates  
     
    From Lorraine to Reims: Joan's Early Life and Public Career
June 12 Readings Régine Pernoud and Marie-Véronique Clin, Joan of Arc, Herstory, chapters 1–4.
  Debates  
     
June 15 Readings Taylor, Joan of Arc: La Pucelle, pp. 68–133.
  Debates  
     
    Frustration and Captivity: The Condemnation Trial.
June 16 Readings Pernoud, Clin, [and Adams], Joan of Arc, Herstory. Chapters 5–9.
  Debates  
     
June 17 Readings Taylor, Joan of Arc: La Pucelle, pp. 134–224.
    Article by Susan Schibanoff in Fresh Verdicts.
  Debates  
     
June 18 Readings Pernoud, Chapter 7 of Joan of Arc by Herself & Her Witnesses in OLR.
    Susan Crane, “Clothing and Gender Definition: Joan of Arc.”
  Debates  
     
    Trial and Death
June 19 Readings Pernoud, Chapter 7 of Joan of Arc by Herself & Her Witnesses in OLR.
    [Also see W.S. Scott, The Trial of Joan of Arc (on reserve and on-line)].
  Film Thomas Edison’s Joan of Arc.
  Debates  

Part 2 - Receptions of Joan by her Contemporaries

 In the Nullification trial and the conversations that led up to it, we see the pressure on her contemporaries to forge images of Joan and images of France. The nullification trial documents themselves are extremely important sources for late medieval social history.
    The Nullification Trial: Joan's rehabilitation in the 1450's.
June 22 Readings Article by Charles T. Wood in Fresh Verdicts.
    Pernoud, Chapter 9 of Joan of Arc by Herself & Her Witnesses in OLR.
    Taylor, Joan of Arc: La Pucelle, pp. 225–329.
  Debates  
     
June 23   EXAMINATION
     
    Inquisitorial Procedures and the Fairness of Joan's Trial
June 24 Readings Taylor, Joan of Arc: La Pucelle, pp. 330–358
  Debates  
     
June 25 Readings Articles by Steven Weiskopf and Karen Sullivan Fresh Verdicts.
    Dossat, “Inquisition” in OLR.Dossat, “Inquisition” in OLR.
    H.A. Kelly, “The Right to Remain Silent…” in OLR.
  Debates  
     

Part 3 - Later Receptions of Joan

 Poets, artists, dramatists, and historians never lost sight of Joan of Arc. In this section of the course, we consider her afterlife as an image of female heroism and hysteria, cunning and madness from the early modern period through the end of he nineteenth century.
June 26   From Christine de Pizan to Shakespeare: Renaissancing Joan.
  Readings Articles by Steven Weiskopf, Christine McWebb, Anne D. Lutkus and Julia M.
    Walker, Jane Marie Pinzino in Fresh Verdicts.
    Christine de Pizan, Ditié de Jeanne d’Arc in OLR.
    Deborah Fraioli, “The Literary Image of Joan of Arc” in OLR.
    Raphael Holinshed, Chronicles in OLR.
    William Shakespeare, 1 Henry VI.
  Debates  
     
    The Nineteenth-Century Joan.
June 29 Readings Jules Michelet, Joan of Arc.
    Voltaire, La Pucelle d’Orléans in OLR;
    Kathleen Wellman, Agnès Sorel in OLR;
    Schiller’s Maiden of Orléans in OLR.
    [Also see scores for operas by Verdi (Giovanna d’Arco) and Tchaikovsky (The Maid
of Orleans
); as well as Mark Twain, Personal Recollections of Joan of Arc. (on
reserve)].
  Debates  
     
June 30   Twentieth-Century Joan.
  Readings Article by H.A. Kelly in Fresh Verdicts.
    “Official Pronouncement of Canonization” in OLR.
    George Bernard Shaw, Saint Joan (1923) in OLR.
    Johan Huizinga, “Bernard Shaw’s Saint” in OLR.
   

[Also see Bertholt Brecht, Saint Joan of the Stockyards [Der heilige Johanna der Schlachthofe], (1932)
and Jean Anouilh, The Lark [L’Alouette] in OLR (on reserve)].

  Debates  
  DUE: WWW Projects
     
   

     

Part 4 - Was Joan Inspired or Crazy?

 Joan claimed that she shaped her life, mission, and goals at the direction of her "heavenly voices" named as the archangel St. Michael, Saint Margaret, and Saint Catherine. Joan in her own day (and in ours?) embodied and symbolized profound religious faith. How has her faith been represented, admitted, and denied? Here we interrogate the figure of Joan and the embarrassment of belief.
    Faith and the Physics of Spiritual Communication.
July 1 Readings John and Isobel-Ann Butterfield, “Joan of Arc: A Medical View” in OLR.
  Films

Martha Graham’s Seraphic Dialogues.

Carl Theodor Dreyer’s La passion de Jeanne d’Arc (1927–28; 128).

    Cecil B. deMille’s Joan the Woman (1916; 127).

Course Requirements and Design:

Assignments:

Four in-class debates/presentations (20% each); mid-term examination (10%) and a final exam or web-based project (10%). For that project, students registered in history must choose a historical topic; in literature, a literary topic; in CF, a comparative topic. All web topics must be chosen in consultation with me and all topics must be approved by or before June 15.

The major part of the semester concentrates on pre-20th century (pre-canonization) images of Joan particularly as she appears in historical records, but also in poetry, drama, and the visual arts. In general, we’ll trace the shift from the historical record to early modern and Enlightenment views of Joan as harlot or medieval zealot through to the nineteenth century revisioning of Joan as patriot and pucelle [maid]. The last part of the course considers various constructions of Joan in the twentieth century, including important dramatic versions of Joan as constructed by Shaw, Brecht, and Anouilh.

The web project must focus on an additional version of Joan from the historical or literary records. Even though it is now somewhat out-of-date, Nadia Margolis’ bibliography (on reserve) refers to a wealth of historical and literary treatments of Joan. Begin studying Margolis soon to locate a text (or texts) of interest to you; remember that you may have to order materials through Interlibrary Loan, which can take several weeks. There are other possible “texts” as well, e.g., Joan in popular culture, etc., or topical approaches to Joan (e.g., modern medical studies of Joan’s voices). Margolis does not include music or the visual arts in her bibliography of Joan, and both these media have interesting examples that you might wish to consider and/or catalogue. SMU’s Hamon Library is a terrific resource in this vein.

Each student is responsible for co-organizing and arguing in-class debates, in addition to making brief topical presentations. No exceptions will be made to the rule that exams will be offered only on the date scheduled; if for any reason you cannot take the exams at listed times, drop the course now. It is assumed and required that you will attend and participate in all class sessions. Plagiarism or other violations of the SMU Honor Code result in automatic failure; if you are uncertain what constitutes plagiarism, consult your student handbook or Criteria. And remember that quizzes are possible; if they become necessary, you’ll know why and who to blame.

Attendance at all classes is mandatory. A single absence constitutes dropping the course.